In this essay, i first provide a brief overview of the history and evolution of police discretion from the 1960s to today and explain how its exercise has been impacted in recent decades by the war on drugs and the adoption of broken windows policing. Issues such as the potential for racism, sexism and socialism are everpresent in everyday policing. To the extent that police departments focus patrols where there is more crime bayley, 2008. The target of the offenders conduct becomes more focused on the police or an individual officer.
Riverahood contends that the trial court abused its discretion in failing to give his proposed instruction regarding the mistake of fact defense to the jury, and. By such decisions, the police define the anbit of discretion throughout the process of other decisionmakers. While administrators are often bound by bureaucratic regulations, law enforcement professionals at lower levels of the organization possess great. Apart from general exhortations to report fully and fairly, officers are given little formal guidance on such. A police officers discretion not to arrest represents the triumph of common sense over the excesses and unwisdom of legislators.
Mulrunji was not an appropriate use of police discretion. Forming suspicion and making a stop abstract most police activity occurs in private, away from the publics view. Discretion among the lower ranks in policing organizations makes control by the organization imperative so that the operational decisions represent the organizations values. Section ii police and juvenile offenders 119 02lawrence45539. Police discretion is a constant consideration within police services. In a domestic disturbance, the police officer has to use his. Drawing on police practices, laws concerning the admissibility of confession evidence, core principles of psychology, and forensic studies involving multiple methodologies, this white paper summarizes what is known about police induced confessions. Police discretion in the 21st century surveillance state. Davis, a police officer has discretion whenever the effective limits on his power leave him free to make a choice among possible courses of action or inaction davis 1969, p. The court then vacated in part and remanded for an evidentiary hearing, findings, and a ruling on equitable tolling, and later denied riveras motion for rehearing. In january 2006, rivera barrientos came upon five gang members while.
In sweden a fivemember committee of parliament has as its primary function the responsibility of overseeing police activity. Primary sources of international law are international conventions, international custom and general principles. Police officers decision making and discretion ncjrs. A participant observation study of game wardens,deviant behavior,27. As for riveras second claim the court held, by agreeing to the fixed term of ten years, rivera impliedly agreed that such a sentence was appropriate. This trend in police work has many advantages such as allowing officers the flexibility to handle each situation in a manner that best fits its individual needs. Police and juvenile offenders sage publications inc. The literature on frontend decisionmaking finds that minority youths are more likely than whites to be arrested, referred to court, and detained by police bishop, 2005, p. Interest in police accountability on the part of police managers, policymakers and police scholars has increased in recent years as a result of three developments.
Handbook pacific islands legal information institute. This creates a situation that allows police officers discretion in the way they think about what they see and how they handle those with whom they come in contact. Labeling theorists, more than 3 decades ago becker, 1963. The court, in its discretion, finds that riveras failure to conform to this vital rule warrants deeming plaintiffs statement of fact unopposed by rivera, and accepting the stated facts as true. The court of appeals addressed and ultimately rejected riveras first claim. In 2006 alone, the nypd stopped, questioned andor frisked over 508,540 people, a 500% increase over the previous year. Understanding discretion in modern policing simon bronitt and philip stenning discretion is a ubiquitous and legitimate aspect of modern policing, though its scope and limits are poorly understood. Police response to domestic violence, 20062015 a n average of 1. Rivera hood contends that the trial court abused its discretion in failing to give his proposed instruction regarding the mistake of fact defense to the jury, and additionally, that the evidence was insufficient to support his theft conviction. Justice department to bring suit against law enforcement agencies where there is a. Rivera barrientos did not leave her house for several days after the attack. Police discretion is defined as the decisionmaking power afforded to police officers that allows them to decide if they want to pursue police procedure or simply let someone off with a warning.
Mar 09, 2010 police discretion is the power or authority that is given to a police officer to act officially in a manner that appears to be just and proper under the presented circumstances. Delord 2006 believed the new generation of police officers needs to feel they will be included in decisionmaking, be recognized for their achievements, and will work for an organization with high moral values. This may include providing aid or assistance to persons in need, such as calling a tow truck for a stranded motorist. The police department is comprised of 120 sworn officers and 79 nonsworn employees who handle approximately 100,000 calls for service each year. Lowvisibility decisions in the administration of justice joseph goldsteint police decisions not to invoke the criminal process i largely determine the outer limits of law enforcement. Police were notified of more than half 56% of these victimizations figure 1. The ij denied riveras application for relief under ina 240ab1 on september 6, 2017. Police discretion allows law enforcement officials to effectively make decisions in the field when no clearcut solution is illuminated by law or a handbook. The problem in the political environment organizational determinants of police discretion is legitimacythe need to justify the departments existence. The role of discretion in policing as a recent development in criminal justice scholarship, researchers have begun to focus on the level of discretion that police officers have in enforcing the law. Appellant has been resentenced several times to correct errors relating to the imposition of consecutive sentences and postrelease control. Proper use of police discretion 2109 words 123 help me.
Cleveland police department was conducting surveillance at 3448 west 59th street due to numerous complaints of heroin sales. Moreover, that knowledge may be faulty in its application to particular cases. The authors shown below used federal funds provided by the. Discretion is the capacity an individual police officer possesses to make a choice among a number of possible courses of actions. Police discretion can be also defined as the individuals ability to make a decision based on the principle of courses in the actions. Number of pages 15 pages 610 pages 1115 pages 1620 pages 2125 pages 26. Introduction this analysis discusses changes in policing that could help build popular legitimacy, i.
High court of lautoka practice direction 1 of 2000 order 34 pre trial conferences and setting down for trial appendix 8. The problem tends to arise when a police officer comes. While police managers have access to technology that enables them to closely monitor the discretion exercised by police officers at all times alderson, 2003, a manager watching an officers every move is a superficial solution, which suggests a lack of trust in the ethics and values of the officer. An evaluation of the role of discretion in policing ultius. Cuttler mj, muchinsky pm 2006 prediction of law enforcement training performance and dysfunctional job performance with general mental ability, personality, and life history variables. Department of justice office of justice programs 810 seventh street n. High court practice direction 2 of 2000 requirement for counsel to be briefed. Although discretion is an unavoidable and ubiquitous feature of police work, it is also the subject of significant controversy and debate. Filed united states court of appeals tenth circuit elisabeth. International law is a set of rules that governs the relationship between subjects of international law, i. These are, in particular, states, public international organizations and individuals.
This opinion is uncorrected and will not be published in the printed official reports. Abstract police officers legitimately have broad powers of discretion to enforce the law. In june 20, the american civil liberties union aclu published a report revealing a gross racial disparity in marijuana arrests. Detailed knowledge of the consequences of police discretion in a wide range of situations could produce dangerous forms of inequity and discrimination. If the police were to follow the laws strictly by the book, they will be perceived to be unfair by the society and possibly rejected rivera, 2006. Because rivera was not otherwise ineligible, the trial court had the discretion to suspend rivera s entire sentence. Deterring racial bias in criminal justice through sentencing. Police discretion is the power or authority that is given to a police officer to act officially in a manner that appears to be just and proper under the presented circumstances. Monitoring the use of discretionary police authority.
This in turn means that to the extent the decision rests on such matters as the resolution of conflicts within the evidence, the development of reasonable inferences of. The ij had misgivings about riveras credibility, but declined to make an explicit adverse credibility finding. An unidentified female was driving and fidel pena, riveras codefendant, was the front seat passenger. Additionally, in 2010, zimbabwes government attempted to regulate international news outlets and prevent negative media portrayals that might encourage violent uprisings against it surette and gardi. People v rivera 2006 new york other courts decisions. Jul 15, 2009 recent dna exonerations have shed light on the problem that people sometimes confess to crimes they did not commit. Police officers exercise a tremendous amount of discretion in carrying out their functions. The third role of police is that of providing services to the public. The most recent nypd data confirms that the police disproportionately target new yorkers of color for stops and frisks.
Police officers are trained on different scenarios that one may come across while they are at the academy. Lipsky 1980 further asserts that discretion among police officers will always be mandatory due to the inevitable lack of resources and the need for an efficient service. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Recruitment and selection of police officers n 67 e. In a domestic disturbance, the police officer has to use his discretion based upon the situation before him. Obtaining identity of prospective defendants a petition for preaction discovery limited to obtaining the identity of prospective. Police discretion police discretion cja342 university of phoenix police discretion police discretion is an important tool in police work due to the law sometimes being too vague or ambiguous. There are also situations in which the law is unclear and the police officer will disregard the different interpretations of the law and utilize his or her discretion in arriving at a decision rivera, 2006. Published by new york state law reporting bureau pursuant to judiciary law 431. The department receives and interprets messages from its environment that suggest how the organization can establish, develop, and maintain supporthow it can sustain legitimacy. Shumaker clerk of court publish united states court of appeals tenth circuit minta del carmen rivera barrientos, petitioner, v. Concluding that rivera hood has waived any claim relating to tendered jury instruction and that the. Use of police discretion two aspects of police decisionmaking with youth were analyzed. Police discretion in contemporary america bernice b.
Before deciding whether a certain action should be pursued against a suspect, the police take into account many factors, at least in theory. Police brutality in nyc for sr center for constitutional rights. United states court of appeals tenth circuit january 11, 2012 elisabeth a. Jul 01, 2012 to the extent that police departments focus patrols where there is more crime bayley, 2008. Process costs and police discretion university of michigan law. Riviera beach is located in southern florida, in the northeastern part of palm beach county. One of the advantages of police discretion is the fact that it allows the officer to humanely treat people, giving them a second chance, and improving on the communitys perception of the police. A difficulty here is that the term discrimination has two quite different positive and negative connotations.
In fact, several countries have surpassed the united states in both recognizing and guiding the exercise of police discretion. In this paper we will examine several important environments to assess. First, section 14141 of the 1994 violent crime control act authorizes the u. Nov 27, 2018 police officers exercise a tremendous amount of discretion in carrying out their functions.
Police discretion essays examples filter results by. Panzarella 2003 suggests that organizational control of police discretion is a facade because police officers are an uncontrollable entity and that an increase in. Filed united states court of appeals tenth circuit. Using the process in this way interferes with other institutional actors ability to limit police discretion. Police discretion not to invoke the criminal process. Recorded with screencastify, the screen video recorder for chrome. Research on factors that influence police discretion usually focuses on. It is seen by many to be both an essential part of policing as well as a constant source of issues. That is, they make many choices from a range of possible actions or inactions available to them, and their choices are not specifically prescribed by law, policy, procedure, or rule.
Police brutality in nyc for sr center for constitutional. Police discretion in the 21st century surveillance state tom tylert i. In the interests of balance, it should also be noted that while we are looking at police discretionary authority in the broader context of what has become known as overpolicing, it. Dan riviello, communications specialist, cambridge police department through this detailed analysis, the crime analysis unit identified that the potential for misuse, or the public perception of misuse, of police discretion increases as. National institute of justice national institute of justice research report t d e p a r m e n t of j u s t i c e o o f f i c e f just i c e p r o g r a m b s j n i j d p b j s o v c broken windows and police discretion.
799 1220 1276 798 166 431 775 327 699 840 74 947 488 1533 1460 527 309 540 936 73 1375 644 1482 1391 389 1265 1158 409 917 1185 949 1114 784 81 24 1174 853 396 949 70 746 566 1036 340 597